Blog

  • WORK INJURIES · MISSOURI & ILLINOIS. Missouri isn't Illinois. Missouri work injuries are carved out of the medical lien. Tell us the state on day one. RSMo 430.230. Dr. Gurpreet Singh Padda, MD, MBA, MHP

    Concussion at work in Missouri: how workers’ comp handles a head injury

    A concussion from a work injury in Missouri is handled through workers’ compensation, not a medical lien. State law takes job injuries out of the lien statute, so a head injury on the clock follows its own billing route. Before your first brain injury exam, Dr. Padda’s team asks where it happened and who referred you.

    Head injuries at work come from falls off ladders, objects striking the head on a loading dock, and crashes while driving for the job. The symptoms match what we see after any concussion: headache, fog, trouble with screens and noise, and poor sleep. What differs is who approves the care and how the bills move. Settling that early keeps the paperwork out of the way of your recovery.

    Why can’t concussion care after a work injury go on a lien?

    Missouri’s lien statute closes with a limit. Section 430.230 says the lien cannot be enforced against anyone who falls under the state’s comp law.1 After a crash on a personal errand, a clinic can wait and be paid from the injury claim. For a head injury you got while working in Missouri, that option is gone. The comp claim carries the care.

    Who chooses the doctor for a concussion at work?

    In Missouri, the employer does. The comp statute requires the employer to furnish care reasonably required to cure and relieve the effects of the injury, and it reserves to the employer the right to select the treating provider.2 A worker may see a physician of their own choosing, but at their own cost. So if the adjuster sent you to us, your evaluation is authorized care. If you came on your own, we talk through what that means before testing begins.

    What protects me from being billed for authorized care?

    The same section says a provider picked by the employer may not bill the worker, or report unpaid charges to a credit bureau, after that provider gets written notice of the comp claim.2 Bring your claim number and the adjuster’s name to the first visit, so our office can route records and bills to the right place.

    What happens when comp denies concussion care?

    A concussion can be hard to show on paper. Many symptoms are ones only you can feel, and a normal head CT does not rule out a brain injury. When the carrier refuses care, the situation shifts. The route usually runs through the worker’s attorney, much like a crash case. We keep testing and documenting either way, so the record shows what changed in balance, eye tracking, reaction time and sleep.

    Does a concussion from work get different treatment?

    No. The state line and the payer change the forms, not the medicine. Your evaluation measures balance, eye movement, thinking speed and symptoms, and the plan follows those results. Recovery also depends on what happens outside the exam room: steady sleep, regular meals that keep blood sugar even, light activity that rises in stages, and a return to work matched to your symptoms. Our article on getting back to work after a concussion covers that last part.

    What if the head injury happened in Illinois?

    We see workers from both sides of the river. Illinois runs its own comp system and treats medical bills differently from Missouri, so tell us the state on the first call. Our page on concussion care for Illinois patients covers how we care for people from the Metro East.

    What should families and attorneys tell us first?

    Four facts: the state where the injury happened, who referred the patient, the claim number if there is one, and whether any care has been denied. Families often make this call for someone too foggy to keep track of details, and those answers are enough to open the file correctly. Attorneys handling comp cases can send the same four facts with the referral. Our page on concussion in injury claims describes how we document the brain injury itself.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is a concussion at work covered by Missouri workers’ comp?

    Missouri handles a job injury as a workers’ comp matter, which is why the lien law does not apply. Ask your employer or its insurer for the claim number.

    Can I see Concussion Center if my employer did not send me?

    Yes. Missouri lets you choose your own physician at your own expense. We explain what that means for your bills before testing starts.

    Will my concussion care change because it is a comp case?

    No. Testing and treatment follow your symptoms and results. Only the billing route changes.

    Where is the Concussion Center located?

    Concussion Center is at 4477 Woodson Rd, Suite 105, St. Louis, MO 63134, near Lambert International Airport. Call (314) 887-5866 or schedule online.

    Head injury on the job?

    Share the state of the injury and whoever referred you. We open the comp file the right way and start measuring what the injury changed.

    Schedule an evaluation or call (314) 887-5866.

    Sources

    • Missouri Revised Statutes, Section 430.230. Hospitals to have liens — when, against whom. Revisor of Statutes, Missouri General Assembly. revisor.mo.gov, section 430.230
    • Missouri Revised Statutes, Section 287.140. Employer to provide medical and other services (subsections 1, 10 and 13). Revisor of Statutes, Missouri General Assembly. revisor.mo.gov, section 287.140
  • Card: "The bumper isn't the neck." About half of people with whiplash still report neck pain a year after the injury. Source: Carroll 2008, Neck Pain Task Force. Dr. Gurpreet Singh Padda, MD, MBA, MHP.

    Whiplash and concussion after a low-damage crash: what predicts recovery

    A crash that barely dents the car can still strain your neck and jolt your brain. When researchers looked at who still had neck pain a year after whiplash, the vehicle told them very little. The person’s own early symptoms told them much more. At the Concussion Center, Dr. Padda’s team records those early signs at the first visit and starts guided movement soon after the crash.

    The same sudden motion that strains the neck also snaps the head back and forth. That is why neck pain and concussion symptoms so often show up together, and why a cheap repair estimate should never close the question of whether you were hurt.

    Does a small dent mean a small injury?

    No. A neck pain task force formed under the Bone and Joint Decade 2000-2010 sorted through 226 articles and accepted 47 sound studies on whiplash. Features of the collision, such as the side the car was struck from or the kind of headrest in the seat, did little to forecast recovery.1 A repair estimate measures the car. Your recovery depends on what happened to your body.

    How many people still have neck pain a year after whiplash?

    About half. That was the task force’s estimate: roughly 50% of people with whiplash report neck pain at the one-year mark.1 For someone who is also dealing with headaches, fogginess or broken sleep after a concussion, a neck that keeps hurting adds weight to an already heavy load.

    Which early signs point to a slower recovery?

    Three stood out in the evidence: high pain soon after the crash, a large number of symptoms, and real trouble with daily life in the first weeks.1 A concussion can push all three higher, because headache, dizziness and light sensitivity add to the count alongside the sore neck.

    Reactions after the injury counted as well. People who were afraid to move, felt down, or coped passively by waiting things out tended to heal more slowly or less fully.1 Those are not character flaws. They are measurable parts of the injury, and they respond to care.

    What happens to the neck in a rear-end crash?

    The seat drives your torso forward while your head lags for an instant. In that moment the cervical spine forms an S-curve, with the lower neck bending back and the upper neck bending forward. The strain falls on the facet joints and on the small muscles that hold the head steady. It is over before anyone could brace, and the same jolt is what moves the head hard enough to cause a concussion.

    Should I rest my neck after a crash?

    Briefly, yes. For weeks, no. When turning your head hurts, you quit turning it, and the muscles that support the neck lose strength from lack of use. The neck stiffens, and the stiffness becomes a problem of its own. We bring motion back early and in measured steps, so inactivity does not turn into a second injury on top of the first.

    How does the Concussion Center track the neck and the brain together?

    At the first visit we record your pain and function, list every symptom, ask how you are sleeping, and watch how you move your head and neck. Those are the same markers the research links to recovery. Care then follows a written plan through our physiotherapy after concussion program, with home work such as the chin tuck for whiplash between visits.

    What should families and attorneys take from this?

    That a picture of a car is not a medical record. The facts that shape how a neck injury unfolds are clinical ones: early pain and disability, the whole symptom list, sleep, and movement. We write those down from day one, as numbers where we can. Our page on concussion in injury claims explains how we document the brain injury side of the same crash.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can a minor crash cause whiplash and a concussion?

    Yes. How much the car was damaged is a poor guide to how much you were hurt. Get checked if your neck aches or you notice headaches, dizziness or trouble thinking after a crash.

    How long does whiplash take to heal?

    It varies from person to person. The review estimated that roughly one in two whiplash patients was still sore at the one-year point. Early, measured care aims to keep you out of that group.

    Is it safe to move my neck after whiplash?

    With guidance, yes. We examine the neck first, then rebuild movement step by step so the supporting muscles do not weaken from disuse.

    Where is the Concussion Center located?

    Concussion Center is at 4477 Woodson Rd, Suite 105, St. Louis, MO 63134, near Lambert International Airport. Call (314) 887-5866 or schedule online.

    Neck pain or headaches since the crash?

    We examine the neck and the brain together, record the signs that shape recovery, and start guided movement early.

    Schedule an evaluation or call (314) 887-5866.

    Sources

    • Carroll LJ, Holm LW, Hogg-Johnson S, Côté P, Cassidy JD, Haldeman S, et al. Course and prognostic factors for neck pain in whiplash-associated disorders (WAD): results of the Bone and Joint Decade 2000-2010 Task Force on Neck Pain and Its Associated Disorders. Spine. 2008;33(4 Suppl):S83-92. doi:10.1097/BRS.0b013e3181643eb8
  • Card: "The bill is the bill." A lien changes when we get paid, never whether. Perfected by certified mail before disbursement (RSMo 430.225 to 430.250). Dr. Gurpreet Singh Padda, MD, MBA, MHP.

    Concussion treatment on a lien after a crash: what you owe and when

    If a crash left you with a concussion, you can start treatment now on a medical lien and pay from your injury claim when it resolves. The lien moves the payment date. It does not cancel what you owe. Dr. Padda tells every patient this before care begins, because a concussion recovery is hard enough without a billing surprise at the end.

    Brain injury cases often move slowly. Headaches, poor sleep and trouble focusing can take time to sort out, and claims tend to wait until the picture is clear. Putting off care until the case is over is a poor trade. A lien lets your recovery and your claim run on separate clocks.

    How does a medical lien work for concussion treatment?

    Missouri law lets a treating clinic hold a lien on your claim against the person who caused the crash.2 You get evaluated and treated without paying at each appointment. When the claim ends in a settlement, judgment or verdict, the clinic’s bill is paid out of that recovery.

    For many concussion patients, the first visits are about measuring what changed: balance, eye movement, thinking speed and sleep. Those measurements guide treatment and give the record a baseline. Starting them early, rather than months later when the claim finally moves, gives both your recovery and your chart a clearer starting point.

    Does the lien law cover a concussion clinic, or only hospitals?

    It covers us. The statute’s definitions name physicians licensed in Missouri as health practitioners, count a group practice as a clinic, and hand both the rights the law gives hospitals.1 People sometimes hear that the lien law is just for the ER. Section 430.225 says otherwise.

    What if my concussion case does not win?

    You still owe the bill. Evaluation and treatment are services, and the charge for them stands whatever the outcome. Our clinic absorbs the wait for the case to finish. It does not absorb the debt.

    Why insist on this? With a concussion, many symptoms are things only you can feel, so the record has to rest on careful exams and repeated measurements. If payment depended on the verdict, every extra visit could look like it was ordered for the case rather than for your brain. A fixed bill takes that question off the table. The plan follows your symptoms and test results, and nothing else.

    How is the lien put on record?

    Missouri requires written notice sent by certified mail with a return receipt. It goes to whoever is alleged to be responsible for the crash and, when known, to that party’s insurer, and it must be sent before any payment goes out to you or your lawyer.3 We send those notices early, so the lien is in place well before the case closes.

    Where does a letter of protection fit in?

    A letter of protection is a second layer that sits alongside the lien. The law gives the clinic its right. The letter states the amount and records your attorney’s commitment to pay the clinic directly from the recovery before funds reach you. Concussion care often spans many visits, so having both in place from the start keeps the terms clear for the whole course of care.

    Can a concussion from a work accident be treated on a lien?

    Not under Missouri’s lien law. The statute excludes anyone covered by the state’s workers’ compensation law,2 so a head injury at work in Missouri is handled through the comp claim. Let us know at the first call if the injury happened on the job.

    What should families and attorneys expect from us?

    The same terms, stated up front, for everyone involved. Notice goes out by certified mail, the letter of protection spells out the figure and the attorney’s undertaking, and the bill is not tied to the verdict. Families know where they stand before the first test. Attorneys know what to expect when the case resolves. Our page on concussion in injury claims explains how we document the brain injury itself.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can I get concussion treatment without health insurance after a crash?

    If another driver caused the crash and you have a claim against them, yes. Treatment can start on a medical lien. You remain responsible for the bill, which is paid when the claim resolves.

    Will my concussion care change because I am on a lien?

    No. Your exam, testing and treatment plan are built from your symptoms and findings. The lien only affects when payment happens.

    Does a letter of protection replace the lien?

    No. The lien comes from Missouri statute. The letter of protection adds your attorney’s written commitment and the amount. We use them together.

    Where is the Concussion Center located?

    Concussion Center is at 4477 Woodson Rd, Suite 105, St. Louis, MO 63134, near Lambert International Airport. Call (314) 887-5866 or schedule online.

    Concussion symptoms since the crash?

    We test balance, eye movement and thinking speed, explain the lien terms in plain words, and start care without waiting on your case.

    Schedule an evaluation or call (314) 887-5866.

    Sources

    • Missouri Revised Statutes, Section 430.225. Definitions — distribution of insurance proceeds — limitation on liability. Revisor of Statutes, Missouri General Assembly. revisor.mo.gov, section 430.225
    • Missouri Revised Statutes, Section 430.230. Hospitals to have liens — when, against whom. Revisor of Statutes, Missouri General Assembly. revisor.mo.gov, section 430.230
    • Missouri Revised Statutes, Section 430.240. Notice to be given. Revisor of Statutes, Missouri General Assembly. revisor.mo.gov, section 430.240
  • Card: "Keep the meniscus." After meniscectomy, the hazard of a later knee replacement was about 3 times higher (Rongen 2017, FIDELITY trial). Dr. Gurpreet Singh Padda, MD, MBA, MHP.

    A knee hurt in the same crash as a concussion needs a plan that keeps the meniscus

    When a crash leaves you with both a concussion and a knee injury, the knee plan should protect the meniscus, the cartilage cushion inside the joint, instead of trimming it away. A common knee surgery that removes torn meniscus tissue has been linked to roughly triple the chance of a knee replacement later. Dr. Padda and our team treat the brain and the knee together, with a plan built to keep you moving and keep that cushion in place.

    A head injury tends to take over the first weeks after an accident. Headaches, fog and poor sleep get the attention, and a sore knee gets pushed down the list. Then someone mentions an MRI and a quick scope, and it sounds like the simple fix. It often is not.

    Why does a knee injury matter during concussion recovery?

    Recovery from a concussion is not a matter of lying still for months. Our care builds activity back in planned steps, and a painful knee can stall that progress. A knee operation followed by a long, quiet stretch on the couch adds more inactivity to a body that is already trying to heal a brain.

    We write often about the body’s metabolic state, sometimes called its terrain, and how it shapes brain recovery. Our post on why two people with the same concussion recover differently covers that link. Insulin resistance, extra pounds and inactivity work against the brain, and they work against knee cartilage too.

    What does the meniscus do?

    You have two in each knee. They are C-shaped pads of tough, rubbery tissue wedged between the femur (thigh bone) and the tibia (shin bone), and they share out the load every time you stand, walk or climb stairs. Take part of one away and that load lands on less cartilage, which then wears down sooner.

    What happens to a knee after meniscus surgery?

    A long US study called the Osteoarthritis Initiative compared 335 adults aged 45 to 79 who had an arthroscopic meniscectomy with 335 similar adults who did not. All had knee arthritis or were at risk for it. In the surgery group, 18.8% went on to a replacement of that same knee, compared with 11.1% of the matched group, a hazard about three times higher.1

    The FIDELITY trial asked whether the operation even helps. Doctors in Finland randomly assigned 146 people aged 35 to 65 with a worn, degenerative tear to a real partial meniscectomy or a sham procedure in which nothing was removed. After 12 months, the two groups reported nearly identical gains.2 Five years later, the real-surgery group had:

    • Slightly more arthritis changes on knee X-rays3
    • More knees that caught or locked, an adjusted gap of 18 percentage points3
    • Faster growth of bone spurs on MRI, at odds of 2.86 to 14

    Those studies looked at worn knees, not fresh injuries from a collision. Still, many adults in a crash bring a knee with some wear already in it, and the lesson about keeping tissue applies to them.

    How is the knee treated while the brain heals?

    Our goal is to protect the tissue and keep you active enough to recover on both fronts:

    • Knee injections. A review of 48 randomized trials covering 9,338 knees with arthritis found that platelet-rich plasma (PRP), hyaluronic acid and bone marrow aspirate concentrate (BMAC) each did better than steroid injections for pain and function at six months or more.5
    • Strength and balance training. Our physiotherapy after a concussion program paces knee loading around concussion symptoms, so neither recovery holds the other back.
    • Treating the terrain. Blood sugar, weight and daily movement get the same attention as the knee and the headache.

    Will PRP grow back a torn meniscus?

    It will not, and we say so plainly. A 2019 consensus from the European knee and sports surgery society found no evidence that PRP helps a torn meniscus heal.6 That group named meniscus preservation the first choice, since outcomes after partial removal trail those after repair over the long term.6 Its job here is easing pain and helping the knee work, with the meniscus left where it belongs.

    When should a knee go to a surgeon?

    A knee that is locked and cannot fully straighten, or a new tear that can be sewn back together, needs a surgeon. Repair saves the meniscus instead of removing it. Our exam tells these knees apart before anyone schedules an operation.

    What should families and attorneys watch for?

    If part of the meniscus is removed after a crash, plan for the knee replacement that may come years later, not just the scope itself. The record should show the knee exam, what was tried before surgery, and how the knee works over time. Our page on concussion in injury claims explains how we document both injuries.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can a concussion and a knee injury be treated at the same time?

    Yes. We plan both together. Knee loading is paced around concussion symptoms so that activity can keep building for the brain and the joint.

    Should I have surgery for a meniscus tear after a car accident?

    Not always. For worn tears, a sham-controlled trial found partial removal worked no better than a fake operation. A locked knee or a tear that can be stitched is different and needs a surgeon.

    Can PRP regrow my meniscus?

    No. PRP does not rebuild meniscus tissue. It is used to ease knee pain and improve function while the meniscus is kept.

    Where is the Concussion Center located?

    Concussion Center is at 4477 Woodson Rd, Suite 105, St. Louis, MO 63134, near Lambert International Airport. Call (314) 887-5866 or schedule online.

    Sources

    • Rongen JJ, Rovers MM, van Tienen TG, Buma P, Hannink G. Increased risk for knee replacement surgery after arthroscopic surgery for degenerative meniscal tears: a multi-center longitudinal observational study using data from the osteoarthritis initiative. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage. 2017;25(1):23-29. doi:10.1016/j.joca.2016.09.013
    • Sihvonen R, Paavola M, Malmivaara A, Itälä A, Joukainen A, Nurmi H, et al. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy versus sham surgery for a degenerative meniscal tear. New England Journal of Medicine. 2013;369(26):2515-24. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1305189
    • Sihvonen R, Paavola M, Malmivaara A, Itälä A, Joukainen A, Kalske J, et al. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy for a degenerative meniscus tear: a 5 year follow-up of the placebo-surgery controlled FIDELITY (Finnish Degenerative Meniscus Lesion Study) trial. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2020;54(22):1332-1339. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2020-102813
    • Sillanpää N, Iivanainen M, Turkiewicz A, Sihvonen R, Paavola M, Taimela S, et al. Effect of arthroscopic partial meniscectomy on structural degeneration of the knee – A 5-year MRI-based follow-up of the placebo-surgery controlled FIDELITY (Finnish Degenerative Meniscus Lesion Study) trial. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage. 2025;33(2):276-282. doi:10.1016/j.joca.2024.09.003
    • Jawanda H, Khan ZA, Warrier AA, Acuña AJ, Allahabadi S, Kaplan DJ, et al. Platelet-Rich Plasma, Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate, and Hyaluronic Acid Injections Outperform Corticosteroids in Pain and Function Scores at a Minimum of 6 Months as Intra-Articular Injections for Knee Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis. Arthroscopy. 2024;40(5):1623-1636.e1. doi:10.1016/j.arthro.2024.01.037
    • Kopf S, Beaufils P, Hirschmann MT, Rotigliano N, Ollivier M, Pereira H, et al. Management of traumatic meniscus tears: the 2019 ESSKA meniscus consensus. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy. 2020;28(4):1177-1194. doi:10.1007/s00167-020-05847-3
  • Black-and-white flat lay of small anatomy models, including a brain, a skull and a rib cage, on a gray surface

    Your brain is soft tissue: what a normal CT after a crash does and doesn’t rule out

    A normal head CT after a crash means the scan found no bleeding, no swelling pushing the brain out of place and no skull fracture. It does not mean the brain was not injured. The brain is soft tissue, and the injury behind most concussions is a chemical and energy problem inside nerve cells, which a CT is not built to see. Dr. Padda and our team examine for that injury directly.

    Many people leave the emergency department relieved, and the relief makes sense. The scan answered the most urgent question. The trouble starts a few days later, when the headaches, the fog or the poor sleep arrive and someone points back to that clean scan as proof that nothing happened.

    Why is the brain called soft tissue?

    Radiologists sort what they see into bone and everything else. Bone blocks X-rays and shows up white. The brain, like muscle, ligament and liver, lets them through at similar rates and shows up in shades of gray. “Soft tissue” is the name for that gray category. It is a statement about density on a picture, and it files the most important organ you own in the same bin as a pulled hamstring.

    So when an injury after a crash gets waved off as “only soft tissue,” remember what else lives in that bin. The label says how something looked on a scan. It says nothing about how badly it was hurt.

    What is the ER head CT looking for?

    In the first hour, the trauma team hunts for problems that need a neurosurgeon or an operating room tonight: blood collecting on or inside the brain, swelling that shoves it sideways, a broken skull or spine. CT finds those quickly and reliably. It is the right tool for that hour, and a normal result is genuinely good news.

    A concussion usually involves none of those findings. A hard jolt upsets the balance of salts across nerve cell walls, releases a burst of glutamate and leaves the cells short of energy. Our page on what a concussion does to the brain walks through that cascade. It happens at a scale CT cannot resolve, which is why our concussion diagnosis and testing measures balance, eye movements, reaction time and memory instead.

    How often does the first look after a crash miss an injury?

    More often than most families assume. Studies of trauma care disagree on the size of the problem: somewhere between 1.3% and 39% of patients have an injury overlooked or diagnosed late.1 When one trauma center made that second head-to-toe check routine, its overall miss rate dropped from 2.4% to 1.5%. The people whose injuries had slipped past were the more severely hurt, and six in ten had a brain injury.2

    That study did not test why. One plausible reason is simple: a dazed person is a poor reporter of their own symptoms, and a loud injury elsewhere in the body takes the team’s attention first.

    Why do concussion symptoms build over the next few days?

    Part of the answer is that the body turns pain and alarm down in an emergency. Melzack and Wall’s gate control theory describes a gate in the spinal cord that signals from the brain can close.3 Under acute stress the brain does exactly that, through a set of chemical systems researchers call stress-induced analgesia, and its strength varies widely between people.4 In one emergency clinic, more than a third of alert, clear-thinking patients (37%) said the injury did not hurt when it happened, and a few went nine hours or longer before it did.5 In the 1940s the surgeon Henry Beecher noticed that many soldiers with severe battle wounds did not ask for anything for pain.6

    Attention works the same way. A broken wrist, a wrecked car or a frightened child takes all of it. A mild headache and a little fogginess go unnoticed in that first evening.

    The other part is demand. Most concussion symptoms show up when the brain is asked to work: a full day at a screen, a noisy grocery store, merging onto the highway, a conversation with three people talking at once. The first days after a crash are often spent resting at home, so the brain is not tested until the return to normal life. That is the brain’s version of an injured knee that only complains once you walk on it. Symptoms that arrive late are the expected course, not a sign they are imagined. Feeling fine at the scene proves little, and so does never blacking out; see concussion without loss of consciousness.

    What should you do if your CT was normal but you don’t feel right?

    • Keep a dated list. Headache, light or noise sensitivity, trouble finding words, poor sleep, irritability, dizziness when you turn your head. Note the day each one started and what you were doing.
    • Tell every clinician about the crash. Mention any blow to the head, any whiplash and any stretch of time you cannot remember clearly, even if the ER never asked.
    • Get the exam a CT cannot do. We test balance, eye tracking, reaction time and memory, and we order imaging when the exam or the course of symptoms calls for it.
    • Treat the neck too. The neck is soft tissue as well, and whiplash often travels with a concussion. Our physiotherapy after a concussion program works on both.

    Return to the emergency department, or dial 911, without waiting for a clinic visit if a headache keeps climbing, vomiting repeats, you become confused or hard to wake, one side of the body weakens or goes numb, speech slurs, or a seizure occurs.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can you have a concussion with a normal CT scan?

    Yes. Most concussions leave a normal CT. The scan looks for bleeding, skull fracture and swelling that shifts the brain. A concussion is a disturbance in how brain cells work, and it shows up on the exam, not on the CT.

    Why didn’t my concussion symptoms start right away?

    Stress chemistry turns pain and alarm down in the first hours, and other injuries take your attention. Many symptoms also appear only when you return to work, screens, driving or busy places, which can be days after the crash.

    Should I get an MRI if my CT was normal?

    Sometimes. MRI can show small injuries a CT misses, but it is often normal in concussion too. We decide on imaging from the exam and how your symptoms are changing, not as a routine step.

    Where is the Concussion Center located?

    Concussion Center is at 4477 Woodson Rd, Suite 105, St. Louis, MO 63134, near Lambert International Airport. Call (314) 887-5866 or schedule online.

    Not feeling right since the crash?

    Dr. Padda’s team measures balance, eye tracking and thinking speed, the parts of a concussion a CT cannot show, and builds your plan from what we find.

    Schedule an evaluation or call (314) 887-5866.

    Sources

    • Pfeifer R, Pape HC. Missed injuries in trauma patients: A literature review. Patient Safety in Surgery. 2008;2:20. doi:10.1186/1754-9493-2-20 (PMID 18721480)
    • Biffl WL, Harrington DT, Cioffi WG. Implementation of a tertiary trauma survey decreases missed injuries. The Journal of Trauma. 2003;54(1):38-43; discussion 43-4. doi:10.1097/00005373-200301000-00005 (PMID 12544897)
    • Melzack R, Wall PD. Pain mechanisms: a new theory. Science. 1965;150(3699):971-9. doi:10.1126/science.150.3699.971 (PMID 5320816)
    • Butler RK, Finn DP. Stress-induced analgesia. Progress in Neurobiology. 2009;88(3):184-202. doi:10.1016/j.pneurobio.2009.04.003 (PMID 19393288)
    • Melzack R, Wall PD, Ty TC. Acute pain in an emergency clinic: latency of onset and descriptor patterns related to different injuries. Pain. 1982;14(1):33-43. doi:10.1016/0304-3959(82)90078-1 (PMID 7145438)
    • Beecher HK. Pain in Men Wounded in Battle. Annals of Surgery. 1946;123(1):96-105. PMC1803463 (PMID 17858731)
  • Card: "Did you black out?" is the wrong place to stop. A year after a mild brain injury, 17% of working adults still weren't working (TRACK-TBI, Gaudette 2022). Dr. Gurpreet Singh Padda, MD, MBA, MHP.

    Getting back to work after a concussion depends on symptoms, not on whether you blacked out

    Most people can return to work after a concussion from a crash, but many need weeks, and some need far longer. Whether you blacked out tells us little about which group you are in. The symptoms you still have, especially at the three-month mark, tell us much more. Dr. Padda and our team track those symptoms on a schedule and help plan a gradual, early return to the job.

    Families often feel relieved when they hear their loved one never lost consciousness. That relief can come too soon. The person may look fine at the dinner table and still struggle to get through a shift.

    Dr. Padda was trained the same way. During his medical training, losing consciousness was treated as the mark of a real concussion. The science of how brain cells react to a jolt has since moved well past that idea.

    Does a concussion count if you never lost consciousness?

    It does. Our page on concussion without loss of consciousness covers this in depth. In short, a hard jolt throws off the balance of salts inside and outside brain cells, and a surge of glutamate follows. The cells then run short of energy just when they need the most of it. That energy gap is the injury, and it shows up whether or not the lights went out.1 You can read more about it on our page explaining what a concussion does to the brain.

    Which early signs point to a slower recovery?

    Researchers tracked 1,507 college athletes after a concussion to see who still had symptoms at four weeks or beyond. Losing consciousness did not raise the odds. Five other things did:2

    • Being unable to recall what happened right before the hit
    • Struggling to focus or keep a train of thought
    • Finding bright light painful or hard to bear
    • Insomnia, meaning poor or broken sleep
    • Having had a concussion before

    If any of these sound familiar after a crash, say so at your visit, even if they seem small. They help us judge how long recovery may take and what to treat first.

    How many people are off work after a mild brain injury?

    More than most expect. A large US study called TRACK-TBI enrolled 435 adults between 18 and 64 who had a job before their injury. All were seen at one of 11 major trauma centers for a mild brain injury, the same label that covers most concussions.3

    • Two weeks after the injury, 59% had not gone back to work.
    • A full year later, 17% still had not.
    • Over one in five earned less in a year than before the injury.

    For a family, those numbers mean missed paychecks, a changed routine, and sometimes a career that bends in a new direction.

    Why does the three-month check matter so much?

    Because it sorts people. In TRACK-TBI, those reporting three or more concussion symptoms three months out were less likely to be on the job a year after the crash: 73% were working, compared with 89% of those reporting two or fewer.3

    That is why we do not ask about symptoms one time and close the chart. We count them at follow-up visits and again around three months, then aim treatment at whatever is still holding you back. Our concussion diagnosis and testing page lists the balance, eye movement and memory tests we use.

    What helps you get back on the job?

    Three things stand out, and all of them start early:

    • Steady follow-up. Symptoms are counted on a schedule so changes are caught.
    • Better sleep. Insomnia is one of the warning signs, so we treat it directly instead of waiting for it to pass.
    • Changes at work in the first three months. In TRACK-TBI, employees offered help such as sick leave, shorter hours, a modified schedule or other tasks were working more often at one year, 86% versus 72%.3

    Our physiotherapy after a concussion program adds graded activity, balance work and testing so your tolerance for a full day can build back step by step.

    What if the ER chart barely mentions your head?

    That happens often. Emergency care focuses on dangers that need action in the next few hours. A study from one Minnesota county reviewed 1,678 brain injury events and found no Glasgow Coma Scale score for 74% of them. Nearly half, 49%, never got a CT of the head.4

    A blank space in the chart does not mean the injury was small. It means it still needs to be measured and written down. Families and attorneys can learn how that record gets built on our page about concussion in injury claims.

    Some signs need an emergency department right away, not a clinic visit: a headache that keeps getting worse, repeated vomiting, confusion, new weakness or numbness, or trouble waking up.

    Frequently asked questions

    How long after a concussion can I go back to work?

    It varies. In one large study, most adults with a mild brain injury were working by one year, but more than half were still off work at two weeks. A gradual return, planned with your physician, works better than an all-or-nothing date.

    Is it a real concussion if I did not lose consciousness?

    Yes. Most concussions happen without passing out. The brain injury comes from a chemical and energy disruption inside brain cells, which happens with or without a blackout.

    What should I ask my employer for after a concussion?

    Ask about options like sick leave, shorter hours, a changed schedule or different tasks for a while. In one study, workers offered that kind of help early were more likely to be working a year later.

    Where is the Concussion Center located?

    Concussion Center is at 4477 Woodson Rd, Suite 105, St. Louis, MO 63134, near Lambert International Airport. Call (314) 887-5866 or schedule online.

    Sources

    • Giza CC, Hovda DA. The new neurometabolic cascade of concussion. Neurosurgery. 2014;75 Suppl 4:S24-S33. doi:10.1227/NEU.0000000000000505
    • Zuckerman SL, Yengo-Kahn AM, Buckley TA, Solomon GS, Sills AK, Kerr ZY. Predictors of postconcussion syndrome in collegiate student-athletes. Neurosurgical Focus. 2016;40(4):E13. doi:10.3171/2016.1.FOCUS15593
    • Gaudette É, Seabury SA, Temkin N, Barber J, DiGiorgio AM, Markowitz AJ, Manley GT. Employment and economic outcomes of participants with mild traumatic brain injury in the TRACK-TBI study. JAMA Network Open. 2022;5(6):e2219444. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.19444
    • Malec JF, Brown AW, Leibson CL, Flaada JT, Mandrekar JN, Diehl NN, Perkins PK. The Mayo classification system for traumatic brain injury severity. Journal of Neurotrauma. 2007;24(9):1417-1424. doi:10.1089/neu.2006.0245
  • An old world map on a table with a magnifying glass and a closed notebook resting on it

    Uncertainty makes crash symptoms worse, and a clear plan is part of the treatment

    Yes, uncertainty makes crash symptoms worse. When you don’t know what is hurt, how long it will last or what to do tomorrow, your nervous system stays on guard and turns the pain up. A clear explanation of the injury and a written plan are not courtesy. They are part of the treatment.

    I have been chewing on this since October 11. It was close to 5:50 on a Sunday morning, and I was on my way to work out when I spotted flames from a car on the highway and pulled over. I helped the woman inside get clear. As I steered her to the shoulder, another driver hit me hard and fled. She did well. I told the longer version in my post on how adrenaline can mask an injury after a crash.

    The tally: two fractures in my left leg (medial malleolus and fibula), a roughly 15 cm cut at the ankle through the tibial artery, blood loss near 40% of total volume, two broken ribs, and activation of the trauma team. No surgery. The wound was closed.

    Why did I have so much pain and so little suffering?

    When the adrenaline drained away, the pain showed up in full. The suffering mostly never did. Five things I happened to have explain why.

    • The injury made sense to me. I could name every broken part.
    • I had a plan for the next day and the next month.
    • I had a reason: the injury came from stopping for a stranger.
    • I had people around me.
    • I expected to get better.

    Reverse each one and you get the four forces that convert pain into suffering: fear, isolation, uncertainty and meaninglessness. None of them is a fixed trait. You can work on every one, and so can the clinician across the desk from you. Crashes produce one of them in bulk: not knowing.

    Can not knowing what is wrong really make pain stronger?

    It can, and someone measured it. In a 2013 brain-imaging experiment, volunteers saw other people’s ratings of a heat stimulus, then received it. When those ratings were uncertain, the identical heat hurt more. The extra pain tracked activity in the periaqueductal gray, a small midbrain hub that helps set the gain on incoming pain. The researchers titled the paper with the finding: uncertainty increases pain.

    That was heat in a scanner, not a wreck on the interstate. Still, the logic travels. After a collision the open questions stack up fast. Is my neck broken? Will this headache lift? Can I work Monday? Every question left hanging is one more reason for your brain to stay on high alert, and a brain on high alert reports more pain from the same tissue.

    How do fear and being alone feed crash symptoms?

    Fear grows in the gap where information should be. A 2022 meta-analysis pooled 335 studies and 65,340 people living with clinical pain. Catastrophizing (assuming the worst) and fear of pain tracked disability, anxiety, depression and negative mood with medium-to-large strength, and tracked pain intensity with medium strength. Those are associations, not proof of cause.

    Isolation works the same angle from another side. In one small experiment, people who viewed a picture of their partner rated a lab pain stimulus lower. Company changes the signal. So if you were hurt in a crash, bring someone to your visits, let people help, and don’t try to sort this out alone at 2 a.m. with a search engine.

    What does a clear explanation actually do?

    It swaps a guess for a fact. The trick is that the explanation has to come from a real exam, not from reassurance. Right after a crash, the first job is to find out what is damaged. That is why our diagnosis and testing looks at balance, eye movement, memory, the neck and the nerves, and does not just ask how much it hurts.

    Once we know, understanding the pain changes the pain. A 2022 randomized trial in 151 adults with chronic back pain tested pain reprocessing therapy, which teaches people to read their pain as a signal from the brain rather than as proof of fresh damage. After treatment, 66% reported being pain-free or close to it; the figures were 20% with placebo and 10% with usual care. Brain responses to back pain dropped in the anterior midcingulate and anterior prefrontal cortex, and the gains held at one year. Different injury, same lesson: meaning shapes pain.

    What should a recovery plan after a crash include?

    A plan you can read back at home, in plain words. When I build one with a patient, it answers four questions:

    1. What is injured, by name, and what is not.
    2. What we do this week: movement, sleep, the specific physiotherapy after a concussion or whiplash, and any medicine.
    3. Which signs mean come back sooner.
    4. When we expect you to feel better, and what we change if you don’t.

    That fourth item matters more than people think. Expecting to recover is not wishful thinking when it rests on a diagnosis and a timeline. The rest of our approach is laid out under concussion treatment.

    Where do opioids fit after a car accident?

    Where the individual needs them, and no further. In the ER I was offered opioids several times and said no each time. Reason one: long-term use usually begins with a first exposure. There was no sense in starting a medicine I might never require. A CDC analysis of opioid-naive adults showed the odds of long-term use rising with each extra day in the first supply, and the biggest steps came past day 5 and past day 31. Reason two: in those early hours my endorphin and epinephrine levels were carrying most of the load, so I felt little pain.

    My toolkit in the first days: ibuprofen with acetaminophen, TENS, EMS, vibration from a small plate aimed at the injury, and infrared light. An ED trial of 411 adults with acute arm or leg pain found a single dose of ibuprofen plus acetaminophen relieved pain at two hours about as well as three opioid combinations. I missed no work and was back to full procedure days on October 26.

    That was my choice in my body. It may not be yours, and I am not a martyr for making it. Some patients genuinely need an opioid, and they deserve one. Opioid stewardship, as we practice it, is individualized harm reduction, not a ban: the lowest exposure that works, with function protected. We treat patients as we find them, not as we anticipate them. For people already taking opioids, we use interventional procedures to help them taper while keeping them out of withdrawal.

    Why does meaning matter after a crash?

    Viktor Frankl, who wrote Man’s Search for Meaning after surviving the Nazi camps, put it this way: “Suffering ceases to be suffering at the moment it finds a meaning, such as the meaning of a sacrifice.” That sentence describes October 11 better than I can. My injury came from stopping for someone in danger, and that reason kept the fracture from becoming something heavier.

    Death is not abstract to me. I have been exposed to it more than once, directly and indirectly, and this month’s wreck cost me about 40 percent of my blood volume. The Stoics had a habit for this, memento mori, a Latin phrase meaning “remember that you will die.” Its purpose was proportion, not gloom. It was a ruler. Hold a hardship up against the shortness of life and it shrinks to its true size. A broken ankle is a problem with a timeline, not a catastrophe. Epictetus named the mechanism in the Enchiridion (section 5, George Long’s translation): “Men are disturbed not by the things which happen, but by the opinions about the things.” After a crash, uncertainty writes the darkest opinions, and a clear diagnosis rewrites them. None of this means going quiet or gritting your teeth. Give your clinician the real pain score, since the plan depends on it. A patient who requires an opioid has failed at nothing.

    One more thing an explanation cannot replace: a headache that keeps building, repeated vomiting, confusion, unusual drowsiness, or new weakness or numbness after a crash means an emergency department today, not an appointment next week.

    Frequently asked questions

    Why does my pain feel worse when nobody can tell me what is wrong?

    Because uncertainty keeps the brain’s threat system switched on, and that system amplifies pain. In a 2013 experiment, the same heat hurt more when people were unsure what to expect. Getting a real diagnosis is one of the fastest ways to take that pressure off.

    Does worrying about my symptoms slow my recovery?

    Worry is not a character flaw; it is what a brain does with missing information. Across hundreds of studies, fear of pain and expecting the worst travel with more disability and stronger pain. The fix is information and a plan, not a lecture about staying positive.

    Should I bring someone with me to my appointments?

    Yes, if you can. A second set of ears helps you remember the plan, and simple social connection measurably eased pain in lab studies. Recovering alone adds isolation to the injury.

    Is it wrong to take an opioid after a crash?

    No. Some people need one, and untreated severe pain has its own costs. The goal is the smallest exposure that does the job, chosen for you as an individual, alongside the non-opioid tools that work for many people.

    Sources

    • Yoshida W, Seymour B, Koltzenburg M, Dolan RJ. Uncertainty increases pain: evidence for a novel mechanism of pain modulation involving the periaqueductal gray. Journal of Neuroscience. 2013;33(13):5638-5646. doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4984-12.2013
    • Rogers AH, Farris SG. A meta-analysis of the associations of elements of the fear-avoidance model of chronic pain with negative affect, depression, anxiety, pain-related disability and pain intensity. European Journal of Pain. 2022;26(8):1611-1635. doi:10.1002/ejp.1994
    • Master SL, Eisenberger NI, Taylor SE, Naliboff BD, Shirinyan D, Lieberman MD. A picture's worth: partner photographs reduce experimentally induced pain. Psychological Science. 2009;20(11):1316-1318. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9280.2009.02444.x
    • Ashar YK, Gordon A, Schubiner H, et al. Effect of Pain Reprocessing Therapy vs Placebo and Usual Care for Patients With Chronic Back Pain: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Psychiatry. 2022;79(1):13-23. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2021.2669
    • Shah A, Hayes CJ, Martin BC. Characteristics of Initial Prescription Episodes and Likelihood of Long-Term Opioid Use – United States, 2006-2015. MMWR. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. 2017;66(10):265-269. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm6610a1
    • Chang AK, Bijur PE, Esses D, Barnaby DP, Baer J. Effect of a Single Dose of Oral Opioid and Nonopioid Analgesics on Acute Extremity Pain in the Emergency Department: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA. 2017;318(17):1661-1667. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.16190
  • Card: Neck pain after a crash is a complaint, not a diagnosis. A single neck block was falsely positive 63% of the time; controlled blocks confirm the source (Manchikanti 2004). Dr. Gurpreet Singh Padda, MD, MBA, MHP.

    Whiplash and concussion often arrive together, and the neck pain needs its own proof

    Whiplash and concussion often come from the same crash, because one jolt throws the head and strains the neck at once. When both happen, the neck pain needs its own answer. A physician confirms its source with an exam and image-guided diagnostic blocks, so headaches and dizziness from the neck are not blamed on the brain, or the other way around.

    Think about what a head injury does to a neck complaint. It hides it. Fog, headache and poor sleep get all the attention, and the neck becomes a footnote. Months later, the neck is still sore and nobody has checked it properly.

    Why do whiplash and concussion happen together?

    Your head sits on top of your neck like a bowling ball on a flexible stalk. In a crash, the car stops or lurches, and the head keeps going. The neck takes the strain of that whip. The brain, floating inside the skull, takes the shake. One event, two injuries.

    You also do not need to black out for either one. Most concussions happen without a loss of consciousness, as we explain on our page about concussion without loss of consciousness. The same is true of a neck strain. Walking away from the car proves very little.

    How can neck pain look like concussion symptoms?

    An injured neck can send pain up into the back of the head. It can make you feel off balance when you turn. It can wreck sleep, and poor sleep makes thinking slower. Every one of those also shows up on a concussion symptom list.

    That overlap creates two mistakes. Some patients get told everything is the concussion, so the neck never gets treated. Others get told everything is the neck, so the brain injury is missed. Sorting the two apart is part of a real concussion workup, along with balance, eye movement and memory testing. The full list is on our concussion diagnosis and testing page.

    What usually causes lasting neck pain after a rear-end crash?

    Often it is the facet joints. These are pairs of small joints along the back of the spine, one set at every level of the neck. A hit from behind moves the neck faster than the muscles can guard it, and the joint capsules get stretched. Their small nerves can stay irritated for a long time.

    Researchers studied 500 patients with long-term spine pain at an American interventional pain practice. In those whose chronic pain was in the neck, testing with controlled blocks pinned the pain on the facet joints 55% of the time. That same paper found that a lone block in the neck gave a false positive in 63% of cases.

    Read that second number slowly. If a single shot “worked,” the odds were worse than a coin toss that the joint was truly to blame. Relief alone is not evidence.

    How does a physician confirm where the neck pain comes from?

    Step by step, and with a stopwatch. Dr. Padda and our team start with a hands-on exam of the neck, shoulders and nerves. Imaging is compared against that exam. A scan alone often looks ordinary even when a facet joint is the problem.

    If a facet joint is the suspect, the test is a controlled diagnostic block:

    • Using live imaging, a short-acting numbing medicine is placed beside the nerves that supply the joint.
    • Another day, the block is done again with a longer-acting medicine.
    • After each visit you keep a pain diary, hour by hour.
    • The joint is confirmed only if both blocks help, and the short one wears off sooner than the long one.

    For a patient with a concussion, this has a second benefit. Once the neck is confirmed and treated, whatever headache or dizziness remains points more clearly at the brain. Each injury gets a fair look.

    Is a chiropractor enough for whiplash with a concussion?

    Chiropractic care can be part of getting better, and we respect the work chiropractors do. Movement matters after whiplash. What a chiropractic visit cannot do is examine the brain injury as a physician does, order and interpret the tests, or perform image-guided blocks. That is medical work, and with a head injury in the picture it should be done by a physician.

    We are interventional pain physicians. Our job is to find which structure hurts, prove it, and then treat it. Recovery still depends on you, too: steady sleep, gradual return to activity and rebuilding neck strength. Our physiotherapy after a concussion program covers whiplash exercises and treatments for that stage.

    Why does proof matter if you have an injury claim?

    Patients come first, so the main reason is simple: treatment aimed at the confirmed source works on the right problem. A second reason matters to families and their lawyers. Since 2017, Missouri law (RSMo 490.065) has required that an expert’s opinion be based on enough facts, use reliable methods and apply them reliably to the case. An exam, controlled blocks, a timed pain diary and measured function give a record with that kind of footing. A vague note does not.

    Some signs need an emergency department right away, not a clinic visit: a headache that keeps getting worse, repeated vomiting, confusion, new weakness or numbness, or trouble waking up.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can whiplash cause concussion symptoms?

    A neck injury can cause headaches at the back of the head, unsteadiness and poor sleep, which overlap with concussion symptoms. That is why both the neck and the brain should be examined after a crash.

    How do I know if my headache comes from my neck or my concussion?

    Often you cannot tell on your own. A physician exam, concussion testing and, when needed, controlled diagnostic blocks of the neck sort out which injury is driving which symptom.

    Will an MRI show whiplash damage?

    An MRI can rule out serious damage, but an irritated facet joint often looks normal on it. Image-guided blocks done twice with two different numbing medicines are how the source is confirmed.

    Where is the Concussion Center located?

    Concussion Center is at 4477 Woodson Rd, Suite 105, St. Louis, MO 63134, near Lambert International Airport. Call (314) 887-5866 or schedule online.

    Sources

    • Manchikanti L, Boswell MV, Singh V, Pampati V, Damron KS, Beyer CD. Prevalence of facet joint pain in chronic spinal pain of cervical, thoracic, and lumbar regions. BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders. 2004;5:15. doi:10.1186/1471-2474-5-15
    • Missouri Revised Statutes, section 490.065. Expert witness testimony (as amended 2017, HB 153). revisor.mo.gov
  • A multi-lane highway in early morning light, with a few cars, tall street lamps, bare trees and a low band of mist.

    Feeling fine after a crash is a chemical state, not a diagnosis

    Yes. After a crash, adrenaline and the body’s own endorphins can turn pain down so far that you walk away without knowing how hurt you are. Feeling fine in those first hours tells you about your stress chemistry, not about your tissue, and not about your brain. Get a full evaluation even when nothing seems wrong.

    I can describe this from the inside. It was 5:50 in the morning, roughly, on Sunday, October 11, and a woman’s car was burning on the highway as I drove to the gym. I stopped to help her out. As I was getting her to the shoulder, a second car struck me and kept going. She did well. That is all the rescue needs. The useful part for you is what happened in my body next.

    What did the injury list look like next to the pain?

    Here is what the trauma team found:

    • Two breaks in my left leg: the medial malleolus (the bump on the inner ankle) and the fibula, the slender outer bone of the lower leg
    • Two broken ribs
    • A cut close to 15 centimeters long across the ankle, deep enough to tear the tibial artery
    • Blood loss of about 40% of my total volume, enough to trigger a trauma team activation

    None of it required an operation. The wound was closed in the hospital, and I have not missed work. Standing for long periods is still beyond me, so my share of the procedure schedule has shrunk for now. Update, October 26: I am fully back, on my feet for the whole procedure schedule again.

    Now the part that matters for this site. With that list, the pain I actually felt was modest. Endorphins and epinephrine were surging through my system. If pain had been my only gauge, I would have badly underestimated how hurt I was.

    Why can’t you feel an injury right after a crash?

    Because your brain decides how much of the pain signal gets through, and during an emergency it chooses less. Researchers call this stress-induced analgesia. A threat switches on a descending pathway, tracts that travel through the spinal cord from the brainstem, and that pathway clamps incoming pain traffic before you become aware of it. Several chemical systems drive it at once: the body’s own opioids, monoamines such as noradrenaline and serotonin, cannabinoids, GABA and glutamate.

    Picture the pain line put on hold. Calls keep coming in from the ankle, the ribs and the neck. Nobody upstairs picks up until the emergency is over.

    This is old knowledge. In 1946 the surgeon Henry Beecher noticed that many soldiers with grave wounds said they hurt far less than he expected, and plenty never asked for relief. A 2009 review of the research adds the detail that matters most to you: how strongly the system kicks in varies greatly from one person to the next. The calm of the other driver tells you nothing about your own injuries.

    What can adrenaline hide after a car accident?

    Anything that reports itself through discomfort. Pain is the loud signal, and it is the one being turned down. Quieter signals get buried even more easily.

    That is the trouble with a brain injury. Most concussions happen without a blackout. The early clues are things like a dull headache, fog, a short temper, trouble with bright light or screens, or feeling a beat slow. In a body flooded with stress chemistry, those are easy to miss or to blame on the shock of the morning. When the surge fades, they get their turn. Our page on concussion without loss of consciousness walks through that pattern.

    A strained neck can behave the same way: stiff at first, sorer later. If your neck is part of the picture, start with physiotherapy after a concussion, where we cover whiplash too.

    Why did I say no to opioids in the ER?

    The ER staff offered me opioids more than once, and I turned them down every time. That was my own decision about my own body, and I had two reasons.

    First, the first exposure is where long-term use usually begins, so keeping that initial dose small is worth real effort. I did not want to prime my nervous system for a drug I might have no use for later. The research backs the worry. Among opioid-naive adults treated for acute pain in an emergency department, the ones who filled an opioid prescription were 1.8 times as likely, after adjustment, to be using opioids again a year later. People handed a prescription who never filled it had no significant rise. A separate CDC analysis found that the odds of long-term use climbed with each added day in the first supply.

    Second, I simply was not hurting much. The same chemistry that hides injuries was keeping my pain low. Taking an opioid on top of it would have treated pain I was not feeling.

    What did I use for pain in the first few days?

    Ibuprofen and acetaminophen, plus four physical tools: a TENS unit, electrical muscle stimulation (EMS), a vibration plate aimed at one spot, and infrared light. I call the physical ones distractive tools, and to be clear, I am not trying to be woo-woo. Each one gives the nervous system competing input, so the pain signal has company.

    • Ibuprofen with acetaminophen. A trial randomized 411 people in an emergency department, all with recent arm or leg pain. Just one dose of 400 mg of ibuprofen together with 1,000 mg of acetaminophen cut pain at two hours about as much as three opioid combinations did. It tested a single dose, and it did not look at side effects.
    • TENS. The gate control theory, published in 1965, explains the idea. Signals from large touch fibers compete with signals from small pain fibers at the spinal cord. TENS keeps that gate busy with a harmless tingle. A 2022 review gathered 381 randomized trials covering 24,532 people. Compared with a sham device, real TENS left people with lower pain scores during a session or right after it. The review rated that evidence moderate in certainty and logged no serious harms. New pain and long-standing pain responded alike. In our clinic this is TENS therapy after whiplash, and there is a home TENS unit for between visits.
    • EMS. Electrical muscle stimulation makes the muscle itself contract. For me it was one more input for the nervous system to attend to.
    • Localized vibration. Vibration rides the same large fibers, so it crowds the same gate. Here is how we use a vibration platform after a concussion.
    • Infrared light. Red and near-infrared wavelengths are captured inside the mitochondria by an enzyme called cytochrome c oxidase. ATP goes up, and in cells already primed for inflammation, inflammatory signals go down. I want this said plainly: that work is mostly in lab dishes and animals, some of it in injury models. In the clinic we deliver it as laser therapy.

    The trauma team did the real work. These tools only covered the first couple of days, so an opioid was never part of getting through them.

    Should you refuse pain medicine after a crash?

    Not because I did. This was how I handled my own body, and it may not suit yours. Some patients need opioids, and pain left raw keeps people from sleeping, moving and healing. I had a big stress response, the training to read my own body and a team watching me closely.

    My claim is smaller than a rule. Saying no is a choice that works for some people some of the time, and medicine tends to skip right past it. Every person arrives with a different body and a different history, so we meet patients as they actually are, not as a protocol predicts them.

    That is what opioid stewardship means in our practice: harm reduction fitted to the individual, never a blanket rule for or against the drug. Patients who already take opioids and want a lower dose get a taper supported by interventional procedures, with withdrawal kept off the table the whole way.

    Why get checked when you feel fine after a crash?

    Because the low-pain window is exactly when people skip the visit, and it is when an exam is most useful. A good exam does not depend on how much you hurt. It tests the things pain is supposed to report: balance, eye movement, memory and focus, the neck and the nerves.

    Here that can include a VNG dizziness test, a Kinetisense balance test and a Cognivue memory test, alongside a physician’s exam. The full list is on our page about concussion diagnosis and testing.

    A clean exam is good news you can trust. Feeling good an hour after a crash is not.

    Some signs cannot wait for an appointment. A headache that keeps getting worse, vomiting more than once, confusion, unusual sleepiness, or new weakness or numbness means you go to an emergency department now.

    Frequently asked questions

    How long can adrenaline hide pain after an accident?

    There is no fixed clock. The pain-suppressing response varies greatly between people, so two people in the same car can feel very different an hour later. Judge the injury by an exam, not by how much time has passed.

    Can you have a concussion and feel normal at first?

    Yes. Most concussions happen without a blackout, and early signs such as fog, headache or irritability are easy to miss while stress chemistry is high. Testing balance, eye movement and memory picks up what a quick self-check misses.

    Does turning down an opioid make someone tougher?

    No, and that is not the point of my story. Declining made sense for my body that morning. For someone else, a small, short opioid course may be the right call. Ask the clinician treating you what the smallest plan that still works looks like.

    Sources

    • Butler RK, Finn DP. Stress-induced analgesia. Progress in Neurobiology. 2009;88(3):184-202. doi:10.1016/j.pneurobio.2009.04.003
    • Beecher HK. Pain in men wounded in battle. Annals of Surgery. 1946;123(1):96-105. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1803463/
    • Hoppe JA, Kim H, Heard K. Association of emergency department opioid initiation with recurrent opioid use. Annals of Emergency Medicine. 2015;65(5):493-499. doi:10.1016/j.annemergmed.2014.11.015
    • Shah A, Hayes CJ, Martin BC. Characteristics of initial prescription episodes and likelihood of long-term opioid use: United States, 2006-2015. MMWR Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. 2017;66(10):265-269. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm6610a1
    • Chang AK, Bijur PE, Esses D, Barnaby DP, Baer J. Effect of a single dose of oral opioid and nonopioid analgesics on acute extremity pain in the emergency department: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2017;318(17):1661-1667. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.16190
    • Melzack R, Wall PD. Pain mechanisms: a new theory. Science. 1965;150(3699):971-979. doi:10.1126/science.150.3699.971
    • Johnson MI, Paley CA, Jones G, Mulvey MR, Wittkopf PG. Efficacy and safety of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) for acute and chronic pain in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 381 studies (the meta-TENS study). BMJ Open. 2022;12(2):e051073. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2021-051073
    • Hamblin MR. Mechanisms and applications of the anti-inflammatory effects of photobiomodulation. AIMS Biophysics. 2017;4(3):337-361. doi:10.3934/biophy.2017.3.337
  • Sliced seared steak beside roasted asparagus and cherry tomatoes on a white plate.

    A ketogenic diet for brain injury feeds a starved brain, but the first week can mimic the concussion

    A ketogenic diet for brain injury gives the brain a second fuel, ketones, at a time when it struggles to use sugar. The 2026 guideline from the Society of Metabolic Health Practitioners lists brain energy, brain insulin resistance and inflammation as reasons ketogenic eating is studied in brain conditions. Concussion is not yet on its list, so the start needs a doctor.

    Here is the trap. The first week of a ketogenic diet can bring headache, tiredness, light-headedness, poor focus and mood swings. Read that list again. It is also the list of post-concussion symptoms. Start the diet alone in the weeks after a head injury, and nobody can tell which symptom belongs to which cause. That includes you.

    Why does an injured brain run short of fuel?

    A concussion is an energy problem. In the first minutes, brain cells burn through fuel to restore their balance, while blood flow to the area often drops. Demand goes up as supply goes down.

    Then a second problem arrives. In animal research, brain injury made the brain itself resistant to insulin for days to weeks. Insulin is the signal that helps brain cells take in sugar. So the injured brain sits next to a full tank it cannot easily open. We walk through that research in why two people with the same concussion recover differently.

    Most concussions happen without a blackout. Many people never connect the fog, the screen trouble and the short temper to the hit. The energy problem runs anyway. More on that is on our page about concussion without loss of consciousness.

    What does the 2026 guideline say about ketones and the brain?

    The guideline is about medically supervised low-carb eating for metabolic disease. It has a table of emerging uses. For brain and mental health conditions, it lists these reasons:

    • Ketones give brain cells another fuel to make energy.
    • Ketogenic eating may help ease insulin resistance in the brain.
    • It lowers inflammation.
    • It helps regulate the brain’s chemical messengers.
    • It supports repair and the growth factors that protect nerve cells.

    Read those next to the injury. The brain cannot use sugar well, and ketones go in by another door. Insulin signaling is impaired, and the diet works on it. Inflammation is running, and the diet lowers it. That match is why Dr. Padda treats fuel as part of brain injury care. The guideline itself does not name concussion. It names epilepsy, where the evidence is strong, and lists brain diseases, psychiatric conditions and migraine as uses being studied.

    The guideline is a consensus document, not a trial. Its panel voted on 18 statements, and every one passed. It rests on a review the authors call non-systematic, without formal grading of the evidence.

    Is a ketogenic diet the same as low-carb?

    No, and the difference matters for the brain. The guideline treats carb cutting as a range. Under 130 grams of carbs a day is low-carb. Ketosis usually starts under 50 grams. Some people need to go near 20 grams, and some get there above 70.

    For blood sugar, you do not always need ketosis. For the brain, the guideline notes, deeper ketosis may matter more. That is the line between eating fewer carbs and running a ketogenic therapy. Therapy means a carb target, measured ketones and a doctor who reads the numbers with you.

    Ketosis from food is a normal state. It is not diabetic ketoacidosis, the emergency in people who make no insulin. The guideline says diet ketone levels do not come close to that.

    Why can keto flu look like a concussion?

    When carbs drop, insulin drops, and the kidneys release salt and water. The guideline says the start-up symptoms begin within two to three days. They usually last a few days and sometimes two to four weeks. They include headache, fatigue, light-headedness, poor concentration, mood changes, cramps and cravings.

    Most of that is a salt shortage. The guideline’s fix: 2 to 3 grams of sodium a day for most people, which is 5 to 7 grams of salt. Add potassium from greens, tomatoes, cucumbers and zucchini. Drink at least 2 liters of fluid. Magnesium, 200 to 400 mg a day, can stop cramps if you have no kidney disease or nerve-muscle disease and are not pregnant.

    Our rule is simple. Before you change a meal, write down your concussion symptoms every day for a week. Rate the headache, the fog, the dizziness and your sleep. With that baseline on paper, a salt headache on day three looks different from your injury. Without it, you may quit a diet that was helping, or blame the injury for a fix that takes one cup of broth.

    One more point. Dr. Padda does not let an injured brain go hungry. The guideline sets protein first and fat “to satiety,” and it does not ask you to count calories. A concussed brain running on skipped meals has less fuel, not more.

    Which concussion medicines change on a ketogenic diet?

    This is where supervision earns its keep. The guideline names drugs that can block fat breakdown, including beta blockers, some antidepressants such as fluoxetine, and some antipsychotics such as olanzapine and quetiapine. Seizure and psychiatric medicines can change in effect. Lithium and valproic acid need blood levels checked.

    Mood needs care too. The guideline suggests a gradual start for people with a mental health diagnosis, especially bipolar disorder, because mood can shift during the change. After a head injury, anxiety and low mood are common. Our page on PTSD and post-concussion syndrome explains why.

    Medication changes are made by the doctor, especially insulin, sulfonylureas, SGLT2 inhibitors and blood pressure pills. Never change a dose on your own.

    Medicines for post-concussion symptoms need a look too. The guideline lists NSAIDs, opioid pain medicines and several antidepressants, including amitriptyline, among the drugs that can push sodium too low. That adds to the salt your kidneys release in the first week.

    Who gets hurt when nobody plans the food?

    A concussion often takes away the things that make cooking possible. You cannot focus long enough to plan a week. Bright stores and screens trigger symptoms. Work hours shrink, and so does money. Many people end up alone in a dark room, eating whatever arrives in a bag. That is usually refined starch, sugar and industrial seed oils, the food that drives insulin up and inflammation with it.

    Dr. Padda knows the pull of the standard advice. He was a strict vegetarian for years and preached the food rules he now rejects. A plate of beef at a Kansas City barbecue joint ended that. Today red meat, fish and eggs anchor the plates he prescribes, with real olive oil and no seed oils. The guideline’s own list is plain: meat, fish, eggs, dairy and vegetables that grow above the ground. It notes that a whole-food low-carb diet costs about the same as a standard one.

    His clinic also checks the terrain behind the injury. A fasting insulin above 10 µIU/mL is high risk in his practice, even when blood sugar looks normal. A brain that was already insulin resistant before the crash has less room to recover.

    Where do you start?

    Three steps, in this order. Keep the one-week symptom log. Write down every medicine you take, with the dose. Then book an evaluation, so the injury, the labs and the medicines are reviewed before the food changes. Recovery is not only rest. You can feed it on purpose.

    To see which fuel your body burns now, your physician may order an RQ metabolic breathing test after a concussion before the eating plan starts.

    Frequently asked questions

    What foods help repair brain damage?

    No single food repairs an injured brain. What helps is a steady supply of protein and a fuel the brain can still use. The 2026 guideline’s whole-food list is meat, including organ meat, fish, eggs, dairy and vegetables that grow above the ground. Dr. Padda adds real olive oil and removes industrial seed oils.

    How do I know my body is in ketosis?

    Measure it. A blood ketone meter gives a number, and symptoms do not. The guideline notes that having ketones does not always mean your body has fully adapted to burning fat. For brain-focused therapy, your doctor sets the target and reads the trend with you.

    Why do people quit keto?

    Many quit in the first week, when salt and water loss causes headache, cramps and fatigue. After a concussion, those symptoms feel like the injury getting worse. Enough salt, potassium and fluid, and a symptom log started before the diet, keep that from ending a useful plan.

    Sources

    • Rice SM, Buchanan LA, Calkins MW, Cucuzzella MT, Cywes R, Devine PL, Kalamian M, Kalayjian T, Reynolds DB, Westman EC. A Delphi consensus-based guideline for the implementation of therapeutic carbohydrate reduction in metabolic disorders. Journal of Metabolic Health. 2026;9(1):a152. doi:10.4102/jmh.v9i1.152